What Is American Conservatism?


Analysis · Posted on


Key Ideas at a Glance:

  • Conservatism = Cheerful commitment to truth and realism.
  • American twist: Stems from Founders’ focus on limited government + U.S. geography (big, isolated, new nation).
  • Vs. Progressives: Less utopian, more accepting of human flaws.
  • Big on clear language: Rejects euphemisms (e.g., “affirmative action” = “race-based discrimination”).
  • Change vs. Tradition: “Don’t fix what isn’t broken.”
  • Reforms often backfire: Good intentions ≠ good outcomes.

What Is Conservatism?

  • Core belief: Seek truth and accept reality as it is.
    • Think of it as preferring a “warts-and-all” view of life over idealistic dreams.
  • Why cheerfulness? Conservatives don’t expect perfection. They focus on gratitude for what works, rather than rage over flaws.

American Conservatism’s Roots

  1. Founders’ Vision:
    • Government should stay small to protect personal freedom.
    • Example: Rules should prevent tyranny, not micromanage lives.
  2. Geography:
    • America’s size and isolation (oceans on two sides) allowed unique cultural growth, away from Europe’s old conflicts.

Conservatives vs. Progressives: A Contrast

  • Progressives (called “Leftists” or “transnational progressives” here):
    • Often push big societal changes for “perfect” outcomes.
    • Can become gloomy when their utopian plans fail.
  • Conservatives:
    • See humans as imperfect but capable of good.
    • Value humor and everyday joys. (Ever seen a conservative comedian? Think fewer lectures, more laughs.)

Clear Language Matters

  • Conservatives dislike vague or manipulative terms. Examples:
    • “Taxation” = “Government redistributing wealth.”
    • “Islamophobia” = A misleading term, they argue, used to silence critics of extreme ideologies.
  • Why? They believe Orwellian “Newspeak” (twisting words to control thought) hides truth.

Change vs. Tradition

  • Be skeptical of change:
    • Historical wisdom: “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” (Lord Falkland)
    • William F. Buckley Jr. famously said conservatives “stand athwart history, yelling Stop” to harmful trends.
  • Not anti-progress, but cautious about unintended consequences.

When Reforms Backfire: Examples

Australian philosopher David Stove highlighted how good intentions go wrong:

  1. Medicine solves a disease → Population boom strains resources.
  2. Contraceptives control population → Traditional cultures collapse.
  3. Welfare for single mothers → Incentivizes single parenthood.
  4. Minimum wage hikes → Small businesses shut down, jobs vanish.

Takeaway: Quick fixes often create new problems.

Hope for the Future

Victorian poet Matthew Arnold believed every society has a “saving remnant”—a group that protects culture from chaos. Conservatives hope this group (think teachers, leaders, everyday heroes) can uphold values like free speech, family, and community.

In Summary:

American conservatism isn’t about resisting all change. It’s about:
✅ Trusting time-tested traditions.
✅ Speaking plainly.
✅ Avoiding utopian pipe dreams.
✅ Finding joy in life’s imperfections.

Thought to ponder: Could embracing reality—not denying it—lead to wiser choices? 🌟

▲ TOP