Supreme Court Gives DOGE Access To Social Security Data


News · Posted on


🗝️ Key Takeaways

  1. DOGE Wins Big: The Supreme Court sided with the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) in two cases involving access to personal Social Security data and secrecy around its operations.
  2. Privacy vs. Efficiency: Critics worry about risks to Americans’ private information; DOGE claims it needs the data to fight fraud and improve government efficiency.
  3. Liberal Justices Object: The Court’s liberal judges argued the rulings were rushed and could set dangerous precedents.

What’s DOGE?

  • DOGE = Department of Government Efficiency.
  • Created by a 2025 executive order under President Trump to “modernize government tech” and cut waste.
  • Critics argue it overreaches by collecting vast amounts of citizen data.

Ruling #1: DOGE Gets Access to Social Security Data

  • The Issue: A lower court had blocked DOGE from accessing sensitive Social Security Administration (SSA) records (like medical info, income, citizenship status) over privacy concerns.
  • Supreme Court Decision: Allowed DOGE immediate access, saying it’s necessary for their work.
  • Opposition:
    • Judge Hollander (Maryland) previously ruled DOGE didn’t prove why it needed such broad data access.
    • Liberal justices (like Justice Jackson) called the ruling a rushed overstep: “The Court is fanning flames instead of putting them out.”

Ruling #2: DOGE Doesn’t Have to Share Its Records

  • The Issue: A watchdog group (CREW) sued DOGE to release documents under FOIA (Freedom of Information Act). Lower courts agreed.
  • Supreme Court Decision: Blocked the lower courts, letting DOGE keep its records secret for now.
  • Why It Matters: Critics say this transparency loss makes it harder to hold DOGE accountable.

Why the Controversy?

  • Privacy Risks: DOGE wants access to data on millions, including Social Security numbers and health records. Opponents say this violates the Privacy Act of 1974, which limits how agencies collect/share personal info.
  • Musk’s Role: Elon Musk (Tesla CEO) helped launch DOGE but later stepped back. He once called Social Security a “Ponzi scheme” and pushed for overhauling it.
  • Fraud vs. Overreach: DOGE claims this data will help catch fraud; privacy advocates say the risk of abuse is too high.

What Happens Next?

  • Lawsuits against DOGE’s data practices will continue in lower courts.
  • SSA must let DOGE staff access records, but with safeguards:
    • Background checks and training for DOGE employees.
    • Some data will be anonymized (names/addresses removed).

đź’ˇ Simple Analogy
Think of DOGE as a handyman hired to fix a leaky government roof. To do the job, they demand keys to every room in your house. Some say it’s necessary; others fear they’ll snoop through your drawers. The Supreme Court just handed them the keys.

Stay tuned for updates as legal challenges unfold.

â–˛ TOP